AVI DAVIS

THE BRAIN AND THE TOMB

ADVENTURES WITH THE ARCHIMEDES PALIMPSEST

DISCUSSED: A Large Hole, Geometric Figures, Medieval Prayer, Obscured Mathematical Texts, Christie’s in New York, The Anti-Scribe, Time along a Parabola, Construction of a New Overtext, Invisibility, Potential Properties of Books, The Circumscribing Sphere, Mind v. World, The Shortcomings of Diagrams, Writing as Writing Over, Approaching Infinity, Innumerable Layers

Quid in tanta lacuna dictum, non expunto. So wrote the German classicist Johan Ludwig Heiberg in 1906, after peering at a particularly inscrutable section of the medieval manuscript he had just uncovered in a Constantinople library. “What in such a large hole could have been said, I will not guess.” Heiberg was attempting to translate the words of Archimedes, arguably the most important thinker in the history of science. His frustration arose from the fact that, sometime in the thirteenth century, the Archimedes text had been scraped off, cut up, rebound, and written over to make a Greek Orthodox prayer book, rendering the ancient mathematics nearly impossible to read.

It might seem incongruous for a German professor to be translating ancient Greek into Latin in Turkey in the twentieth century. But this is the least remarkable of the book’s oddities. The text Heiberg faced had been written in the ninth or tenth century CE—a copy of innumerable previous copies stretching back to the original treatise Archimedes wrote in the third century BCE. And almost immediately after Heiberg’s discovery, the book disappeared for ninety years. The Archimedes Palimpsest, as it is now known, is indeed like a pit into which we can peer forever and never see the end.

We begin, as always, with a copy. The long pages of animal hide bear twin columns of dense script—an antique hand already obsolete—interrupted occasionally by geometric figures. Triangles and squares bisect one another; rectangles nestle in circles, as stray line segments float alongside. The document is instantly baffling, its authority suspect. The scribe, raising his knife, pauses to consider the text before his eyes. But it remains unreadable. Ghosts of their original selves, the words and shapes retreat from his gaze, lost within layers of impenetrable meaning. The work of the blade is quick enough, though never complete.

Now scraped nearly clean, the manuscript leaves are cut in two and refolded in preparation for the new text. In a priest’s practiced hand, he writes his prayers perpendicular to the faded lines below. Soon only traces of the older script and the elegant diagrams can be seen under the newest text. And, in the words of the freshly obscured treatise, “Though many worthy eyes will see it, they all will not know it, and none will perceive it.”[1] On the first page of his new book, the scribe writes: “This was written by the hand of presbyter Ionnes Myronas on the 14th day of the month of April, a Saturday, of the year 1229.”[2]

This was the creation of the Archimedes Palimpsest—a book formed by the erasure of other books. The word palimpsest comes from the Greek palimpsestos, “to scrape again.”[3] The book’s modern name derives from the fact that the majority of the folios—manuscript leaves—Myronas used for his prayer book came from a tenth-century copy of the treatises of Archimedes, which now comprises the oldest existing transcription of the ancient mathematician’s writings.

  1. Archimedes. On the Sphere and the Cylinder I, from Reviel Netz, The Works of Archimedes, Vol. I (2004).
  2. William Noel and Reviel Netz. The Archimedes Codex (2007). Most of my understanding of the Archimedes Palimpsest’s history comes from this book. In fact, the inscription read “of the year 6737.” According to the Greek Orthodox calendar at the time, the world was created in our year 5509 BCE, making 6737 equivalent to our 1229 CE.
  3. Abigail Quandt. “The Archimedes Palimpsest: Conservation, Treatment, Digital Imaging and Transcription of a Rare Medieval Manuscript,” in Works of Art on Paper: Books, Documents and Photographs (2002).

We hope you enjoy this excerpt.

To read the full piece, please visit our store to purchase a copy of the magazine.

Avi Davis is from Massachusetts. He now lives in Bushwick, Brooklyn. More of his writing can be found at the blog Some Reservations.

STAY CONNECTED
News on Facebook Photos on Instagram Stuff on Pinterest Announcements by RSS Sounds on Soundcloud Exclusives on Tumblr Updates on Twitter

Subscribe to our mailing list